U.S. Catholic Latinos: liberal on gay marriage?

Joseph M. Palacios Have Latino Catholics become the most progressive political group supporting gay rights in the U.S.? The casual … Continued

Joseph M. Palacios

Have Latino Catholics become the most progressive political group supporting gay rights in the U.S.? The casual observer of culture often perceives that Latino Catholics are one of the most conservative groups regarding family values and faith. Yet the Public Religion Research Institute’s July 21, 2010, report on “Religion and Same-Sex Marriage in California” found that Latino Catholics stand in sharp in contrast to many sectors of American public, especially Latino Protestants, illustrating the sharp effect of religion on Latino attitudes towards homosexuality and civil and human rights for the gay community. Regarding Latino Catholics the report, based on June 2010 polling of 3,351 California adults with oversamples for Latinos, highlights these two social dynamics:

• 57% of Latino Catholics would vote for the legalization of same-sex marriage compared to 22% of Latino Protestants
• Latino Catholics “say they trust the parents of gay and lesbian children more than their own clergy as a source of information about homosexuality.”

These two dynamics illustrate the new face of Latino Catholicism in California. According to the Pew Forum an estimated 31% of California’s population is Catholic. And of that between 40-50% is Latino. This Latino trend helps pull Catholic social attitudes, already more liberal than Protestants, towards greater support of gay rights.

Why is this so? I suggest the following reasons:

Family First: Latino Catholics orient their social lives around the family and extended family even in the context of high Latino single-parent households (estimated 33% of all U.S. Latino households; 36% of all Latino Children in California live in single-parent households). Family solidarity is strong and even though children may not follow “traditional family values” as projected by the church and the U.S. society, parents want to keep their children within the family. It is not surprising that Catholics in general and Latino Catholics in particular, as the Public Religion Research study shows, see that parents learn about gay issues from their children. Their moral and ethical judgments are primarily made through this social reality rather than abstract pronouncements from their church leaders.

Catholic Communal versus Protestant Individual Faith: Catholicism is a communal faith that highlights the life cycle process through the sacraments of baptism, Eucharist, confirmation, and marriage. Families experience their moral lives through communal participation in the sacraments, as well as the Latino community’s cultural observances of Our Lady of Guadalupe, Posadas, Dia de los Muertos, etc. Protestant Latinos, on the other hand, have a faith that is individually driven through faith conversion (“accepting Jesus Christ as my Lord and Savior”) that often separates a person from the Catholic sacramental life cycle process and the social fabric of the Catholic-based cultural celebrations. Fundamentalist Protestantism sees such Catholic cultural practices as contrary to a pure Christian faith. The study illustrates this communal-individual faith difference by noting that Latino Protestants (37%) lean toward a style of religious social engagement prioritizing “personal morality and faith” over a Catholic (59%) orientation that prioritizes “justice and action.”

Latino Catholic Tolerance versus Protestant Fundamentalist Judgment: Catholics allow complexity and ambiguity in moral decision-making since Catholicism is neither fundamentalist nor literalist regarding the Bible. Rather, Catholics can weigh factors such as the Bible, church teaching, and social reality affecting decision-making. Latino Catholics in the United States live in this social context that allows the free exercise of conscience rather than enforced scriptural fundamentalism or bishops’ and pastors’ exhortations in making decisions regarding homosexuality and gay rights– as is often exercised in Protestant fundamentalist and evangelical denominations and now by increasingly doctrinaire Catholic bishops. Further, as noted in the study, Catholic priests rarely mention homosexuality or gay issues in sermons except when forced to by the bishops as happened during the Prop 8 campaign.

Recently same-sex marriage and adoption rights were legally approved in the Catholic countries of Argentina, Spain, and Portugal, as well as Mexico City. It is important to note that modern Latin Catholicism has a dual nature: it is “conservative” in the sense of family communalism and tradition that the church offers, yet it is classically “liberal” in the sense of not wanting the Catholic Church to have power in political life– particularly after the long historical experience of the Latin American Church “meddling in politics.” As Mexicans put it: “No meta en la política.” A sizeable majority of U.S. Latino Catholics shares these attitudes with them. Increasingly they are joining their Latin counterparts in accepting gays and lesbians as part of the social family that is both Catholic and liberal.

Joseph M. Palacios is Adjunct Professor of Sociology at the Center for Latin American Studies at Georgetown University.

Written by

  • Joseph13

    Almost half of the Argentine population is from Italian descent. So would be interesting to compare the attitudes of Catholic Italian from the US.

  • FortBliss

    Well, most Catholic Latinos that I know personally are opposed to gay marriage but accept gay unions.

  • cornetmustich

    Kudos to Argentina, and to the other countries, cities and states supporting marriage equality.Onward, Joe Mustich, Justice of the Peace,And to CT, a marriage equality state since 2008.

  • Alex511

    fr fortbliss:>…Homosexual unions are considered sinful, just as adulterers are considered sinful. However, each person’s choices are up to him/her. Personal freedom and personal choices will decide where we end up after we die.Being glbt is NOT a “choice”. You are either born gay or straight.

  • LibertyForAll

    Homophobia is intolerance which brings no benefit. Same-sex marriage is a right. I’m Hispanic but not Catholic so it’s important that 57% of Catholic Latinos support same-sex marriage.

  • shadow_man

    Homosexuality is not a sin according to the Bible. Any educated Christian would know that. Scholars who have studied the Bible in context of the times and in relation to other passages have shown those passages (Leviticus, Corinthians, Romans, etc) have nothing to do with homosexuality. These passages often cherry-picked while ignoring the rest of the Bible. The sins theses passages are referring to are idolatry, prostitution, and rape, not homosexuality.(Change *** to www)

  • shadow_man

    Homosexuality is not a choice. Just like you don’t choose the color of your skin, you cannot choose whom you are sexually attracted to. If you can, sorry, but you are not heterosexual, you are bi-sexual. Virtually all major psychological and medical experts agree that sexual orientation is NOT a choice. Most gay people will tell you its not a choice. Common sense will tell you its not a choice. While science is relatively new to studying homosexuality, studies tend to indicate that its biological.(Change *** to www)

  • SJames6621

    I’ve been told by an ultra catholic homophobe who is a hook, line and stinker follower of the church fathers that the church is splitting.Shown by the results in Portugal, Argentina, Mexico city, & Ireland (CUs). and all the other catholic countries of western europe where the church is dying and gay people have marriage or similar rights. Except in Italy and Greece, wonder shy.It appears that the people are, and the article pointed this out, sick of the church medling in politics, which includes its supporting Fascist Franco during the Spanish civil war in 1936-1939. And its apparent support for the murderers who ran Chile, and the military Junta that ran Argentina, Where in both nations tens of thousands of people were murdered and simply disappeared.The top down church always tries to tie in with the powers that be, for that is their route to control.It would be wonderful if all the good priests, who, like the German soldiers of the Reich, who followed their orders or got hanged – an estimated 10000 of them “pour encourage les autres”, would do the right thing. And go on strike against the church.And even then the church prob wouldn’t change at the top. And we’d see a new catholic church spring up over time, true to Jesus teaching of his second commandment “love thy neighbors as thyself.And the current pope, brought up in Nazi Germany, would be nothing but a sad sick lesson from the past. To show what happens when an absolutist leader takes over.

  • cristina1999us

    To SJames6621:Not everything that glitters is gold. In Argentina, the gay marriage was approved without previous consultation to the citizens and the policy is very unpopular. Socially, gays are not mistreated but are not accepted either. Not long ago, a politician’s girfriend was caught using the word “gay” to insultr the former Argentinian Federal Reserve chief in an interview for a magazine. Therefore, lets be careful when we say that X or Y country is liberal or more accepting because they have marriage laws in place for gays to get married.

  • schnauzer2

    Posted by: cristina1999us “In Argentina, the gay marriage was approved without previous consultation to the citizens and the policy is very unpopular.”