German home-schooling family loses U.S. asylum bid

A German family seeking asylum in the U.S. so they can home-school their children lost their appeal in federal court … Continued

A German family seeking asylum in the U.S. so they can home-school their children lost their appeal in federal court on Tuesday (May 14), but their lawyers say they’re prepared to petition the U.S. Supreme Court to take the case.

The German government persecuted the Romeike family for their faith, said Mike Donnelly, a lawyer with the Home School Legal Defense Association, a religious organization that is representing the Romeike family.

“It is treating people who home-school for religious or philosophical reasons differently,” he added.

The Cincinnati-based 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals disagrees. The U.S. grants safe haven to people who have a well-founded fear of persecution, but not necessarily to those under governments with laws that simply differ from those in the U.S., Judge Jeffrey Sutton wrote in the court’s decision.

“The German authorities have not singled out the Romeikes in particular or homeschoolers in general for persecution,” he wrote for the three-judge panel in the case, Uwe Romeike v. Eric Holder, Jr.

Uwe Romeike said in an email on Wednesday that his family began home schooling to protect their children from bullying and teachings they didn’t agree with.

“As we were confronted with opposition to our choice we began to feel more and more that our faith required us to homeschool our children,” he said.

Uwe and Hannelore Romeike moved their five children to Tennessee (a sixth child has since been born) in 2008 to escape thousands of dollars in fines and increasing pressure from local police and education officials to enroll their children in school. All German parents are required by law to send their children to a state-recognized school, whether public or private.

The Romeikes are evangelical Christians, and say they should be allowed to keep their children home to teach them Christian values. Before they left Germany, the police forcibly escorted the older Romeike children to school one day. Other German families have lost custody of their children because they persist in home schooling.

An immigration judge in Tennessee granted the Romeikes’ bid in 2010, but the Board of Immigration Appeals tossed that ruling in 2012, arguing that religious home-schoolers don’t face any special consequences that aren’t applied to other families whose children don’t attend school.

The 2012 decision sparked an outpouring of support for the Romeike family among conservative U.S. Christians. More than 120,000 people signed an online petition urging President Obama to let the family stay. Conservative talk show host Glenn Beck described the case as evidence of crumbling religious freedom.

The Romeikes’ legal team plans to request an en banc hearing, which would present the case before the 6th Circuit’s entire 15-judge panel. Approval for such a hearing is unlikely, Donnelly said, adding that the Romeikes are already preparing to fight for asylum in the U.S. Supreme Court.

Copyright: For copyright information, please check with the distributor of this item, Religion News Service LLC.

  • Adder

    Eh, they are not Muslim enough for Obama. He will not protect them.

  • Richard Buxton

    This is such a crock ;

    The family concerned are EU citizens and as such are free to live and work anywhere within the European Union, where they could find many countries which would support their choice to home school.

    That they chose to apply to the US shows this as just another hollow example of christianists abusing their children for the purpose of ” Grand standing” and has nothing to do with any real concern for their spiritual or physical well being.

  • wcdun1

    Wow! A real shocker this administration and Holder were up held in courts. I guess they didn’t fit the social leeches, codependent welfare brand that Obama needs to bring down the country. Oh, that’s right, they are European, whites that aren’t here for a government hand out or milking the system dry and they probably wouldn’t vote Democrat.

    Funny and pathetic it was mentioned in the media that the Administration and Holder, ACTIVELY put money, resources and effort to ensure they were deported as soon as possible, yet OBAMA’s person family members from Kenya are here illegally, living in the open, but noone is blinking an eye to it. 11 million illegals; most social leeches, drunks, criminals, molesters, murderers, Identity thieves and even the worse of the worse illegals that have committed multiple crimes of rape, molestion, and even murder have been let out of some of the prisons and even some liberal judges have released them back out in the public with little to no regard for the citizens or the victims. Truely Pathetic Run Country we live in!

    I’m a retired, disabled vet and I am also a son of legal immigrants from England (father’s parents came over) and Spain (my mom married my dad in the military) . I also have a German Aunt, French Aunt, and Filipino Aunt. My mom’s sisters are married to a Panamanian and Puerto Rican in New York. I’m mixed race so don’t go there on the “R’ word and make yourself look foolish!

    We are tired of the BS the illegals are pulling with mooching off the taxpayers, my one daughter being a victim of Identity thieves twice by illegal mexicans, hit run numerous times in the last 12 years by drunk driving Mexican illegals; three times our different cars were in parking lots in the middle of the day and hit by drunk driving Mexicans; no insurance, no ID, no licences. We had to eat the deductibles and deal with total cars, injuries. Media says that’s not a big deal!

    Lots of LEGAL hispanics/Spanish people don’t want them here!